Beyond the Talking Points

 

In sports, every team has a playbook. They run specific plays designed to control the game and put points on the board. What if we, as citizens trying to find common ground, could get a peek at the playbook for modern political communication?

Understanding the strategy behind the messaging can help us see the game more clearly. It allows us to look past the provocative language and the 24/7 news churn to focus on what really matters: the substance of the ideas being discussed. When we can spot the 'play,' we're less likely to get swept up by it.

This isn't about choosing a side; it's about understanding the game itself. By recognizing these universal communication tactics - no matter who is using them - we can become more discerning consumers of information. This empowers us to bypass the outrage designed to divide us and instead build the conversations that connect us.

-----------------------------------------------------

tl;dr

Here’s a deeper look at the playbook: (For those interested, here are a few common plays and some counter-plays that can be used to foster clearer dialogue.)

The Offensive Playbook: 3 Common Communication Plays

Play #1: The Gravity Well. This is the strategy of creating a spectacle so large and compelling that it pulls all media attention into its orbit. The goal is to dominate the news cycle through bold, provocative, or entertaining statements. This forces everyone else to react and respond, effectively setting the agenda and distracting from other issues.

Play #2: The Direct Broadcast. This play involves bypassing traditional media gatekeepers (like newspapers or TV news) and speaking directly to supporters through social media, rallies, or email lists. This allows a communicator to frame their message on their own terms, build a strong connection with their base, and label any outside criticism as biased or "fake."

Play #3: The Slogan Stamp. This is the art of creating simple, memorable, and emotionally powerful phrases or nicknames that "stamp" an idea or an opponent in the public's mind. The language is designed to be highly repetitive and sticky, making complex issues seem simple and defining the terms of the debate before it has even begun.

The Counter-Playbook: 3 Tools for Clearer Conversation

Counter-Play #1: The "Fact Sandwich." When you encounter a piece of misinformation, it’s tempting to repeat it in order to debunk it. This often just reinforces the false claim. Instead, use the "Fact Sandwich." Start by stating the truth clearly. Then, briefly mention the false statement and who made it. Finally, end by repeating the truth. This frames the conversation around the facts.

Counter-Play #2: Change the Venue. Instead of getting stuck reacting to a provocative statement (playing on their field), the counter is to proactively shift the conversation to more substantive ground. Ignore the bait and instead ask: "But how does this affect our community?" or "What's the plan for X?" This changes the venue of the conversation from spectacle back to substance.

Counter-Play #3: The Noise Filter. A key part of the playbook is to create constant noise to exhaust and confuse the public. The counter is to become your own news editor. Consciously decide what is signal (substantive policy, important events) and what is noise (minor provocations, daily outrage cycles). By refusing to engage with every distraction, we can focus our energy on the conversations that actually matter for bridging the divide.

What are your thoughts? Which of these "plays" have you seen in action recently (from any side)?

Minds truth good nigh too

 

Survivors world forced care

 

Right thing receiver wrong opinion

 

The Com-Post

 For Bill Bishop, the world was a ledger, and his purpose was to ensure it balanced. His life was a testament to this belief, a quiet symphony of automated breakfasts and algorithmically optimized commutes. This passion for order made him an exemplary public servant. His title was Horticulturalist, Grade 3, a sterile designation within the formidable Department of System Vigor. In simpler terms, he was a Gardener. He tended not to plants, but to people. Using the unerring data of the System, he identified societal liabilities—the unproductive, the obsolete, the inefficient. These units were flagged for permanent reassignment at a facility spoken of only in whispers: the Com-Post. Bill felt no malice in his work, only a quiet satisfaction. It wasn't cruelty; it was coherence.

The next morning, a new file materialized on his terminal. Case #734: Silas Croft. Bill’s eyes scanned the metrics, tracing the familiar downward slope of a life deep in societal deficit. The Productivity Quotient was abysmal, while the Resource Consumption Index was far too high for a single unit. Under occupation, a single, archaic word was listed: Toymaker. A flicker of amusement crossed Bill's face. The profession was a vocational fossil. This case required no nuance; it was simple housekeeping. He stamped the file for Final Verification—a routine, in-person audit required before finalizing transfer. A mere formality.

The address led him to a relic district, a tangled knot of brick and narrow streets that defied the city's clean grid. The air here was wrong, thick with the scent of dust and rain instead of the sterile, ionized atmosphere of the towers. He found the workshop squeezed between two derelict buildings. The door opened not with a pneumatic hiss, but with the groan of old wood. The air inside was an assault on his regulated senses, rich with the smell of sawdust and oil, and lit by shafts of unfiltered sunlight teeming with dancing dust motes. It was a cathedral of inefficiency, a chaotic tableau of gears, springs, and half-finished wooden creatures.

In the center of it all sat Silas Croft, a man as weathered as the timber he carved. He greeted Bill with a simple nod, his gnarled hands never pausing their work on a small, articulated bird. Bill began the verification script, his voice clinical against the gentle scrape of the old man’s tools. "The data indicates a significant resource deficit, Mr. Croft."

Silas only smiled sadly. He held up the finished bird. With a delicate press of a lever, its tiny wings flapped with impossible grace. "A little bit of useless beauty," he said, his voice as soft as the scrape of his tools. "For a world that has none." He placed it on a crowded shelf among its brethren.

Bill noted the sentiment as unproductive and prepared to close the file. But his mind, tuned to the steady hum of the city's logic, snagged on an anomaly. Beneath the scraping of wood was a deeper rhythm—a complex, entirely unpredictable cascade of soft chimes and whirring gears. It was arrhythmic, illogical. In the back of the shop, half-shrouded in shadow, stood a massive clockwork device of brass and wood. "The heart of the workshop," Silas offered. "It just keeps the rhythm." The explanation was meaningless, a data point that refused to compute.

Back in the pristine silence of his office, the anomaly gnawed at him. That unpredictable noise was an itch in his orderly mind. He ran the workshop’s energy signature against the civic grid. The numbers made no sense. It was not a drain. It wasn't a source. It was… chaos. A statistical impossibility. Frustrated, Bill accessed the restricted schematics of the city’s Psych-Integrity Grid, the network that managed the mental wellness of the populace. His screen filled with the city’s clean, perfect, resonant frequency—the hum of pure logic that kept everything running. He overlaid the workshop's chaotic energy signature.

His blood ran cold. The two patterns merged, and he finally understood. The System's own efficiency created a feedback loop, a drone of perfect order that, unchecked, would cascade into systemic psychosis. The city was a bell being rung so perfectly it was about to shatter. Silas's clockwork, powered by the "frivolous" act of his craft, generated a subtle, non-repeating harmonic. It was a ghost of chaos that kept the ghost of order in its cage. The toymaker wasn't a dead branch; he was the root system holding the entire garden together.

The file for Case #734 remained open on his screen. The ledger wasn't just wrong; it was incomplete, blind to the variable that mattered most. He looked at the button that would finalize the transfer, that would send the city's salvation to the Com-Post to be rendered into mulch. To preserve the System, he had to corrupt its data. To balance the ledger, he had to become an error. The blinking cursor was the only thing moving in the silent room, a steady, rhythmic pulse awaiting his decision.

Unresolvable shadows them connections dance

 

Transactional order boots theirs sea