Monday, January 28, 2013

Myth of the Makers (Part 1)


At the heart of the conservative economic argument is the idea that a small number of people make things, while everyone else lives off their ability. These special few who are the designers, inventors and creators that provide the masses with goods and services. The libertarian view expounds that the general public should cater to the needs of these special few so that everyone else can benefit from the their genius.

The selfish man carries the
world on his shoulders?
The basic philosophy of the conservatives is based on the idea of the 'Virtue of Selfishness'.  It argues that  businessmen, innovators and builders are 'Makers'. 

Makers provide things everyone needs. Makers are superior humans due to their skill, talent, and force of will. Makers act in their own self interest using their genius,talent, and creativity to provide things for many other people. Makers add value to their community and are rewarded in return by money and power. When the society diverts resources from the makers, it is essentially an evil that will ruin all.

This view of selfishness as a 'moral good' has as one of its basic ideas that most people are not Makers, rather, most people are 'Takers'. Takers use the things and services given them by the Makers. Takers are inferior humans because they lack skill, talent and/or will. Takers act in their own self interest taking away from the makers, giving nothing in return; essentially stealing from the Makers. Takers drag down society and will ruin it all because they divert the resources of the Makers.

What selfishness means.
There are several assumptions to the Makers argument. They are:
  1. Makers create wealth.
  2. Makers act alone.
  3. Few people are Makers.
  4. Makers always benefit society.
  5. Without Makers society collapses.
  6. Makers know best how to use resources.

Every one of the assumptions about Makers can be challenged using reason. The concept of Makers and Takers can be dis-proven as rationalized myth. These stories about Makers serve only the purpose of allowing a few people with power to maintain that power. The myth of the maker is therefore propaganda.

Unselfish acts of labor.
Here is a brief list of the reasons the assumptions of the makers are false:
  1. Wealth is more than money.
  2. Makers have an obligation to society
  3. Makers are in an interconnected society
  4. Everyone is a maker.
  5. Makers can hinder society.
  6. Makers can do great evil.
  7. We have an over abundance of makers.
  8. Those who control the resources shut out those who do not.
  9. Selfish makers can hurt us all.
Over the next two posts, I'll be examining each one of the assumptions about Makers demonstrating how the logic used in these arguments does not hold up to the facts of the reality we live in.

No comments:

Post a Comment